Since I had the Charlie's Magic Chalk Dust version of PB&J last month, it is inevitable I compare the two. CMCD's version was much more pronounced, and had a really strong peanut butter aftertaste, which I liked, but it was based on the classic grape jelly which gets old for me. This one the flavors were a little more subdued, but you still get a nice nuttiness from the peanut butter. I believe the jelly on this one to be Apple, which is one the few fruit flavors I enjoy. It adds just the right amount of tartness to cut through the nuttiness. While after trying the other I do wish the peanut butter was more pronounced on this one, I still give this a 5, because it is tasty!